Your CIP system is working. The equipment is being cleaned, the cycles are running, and production is resuming normally.
However, cleaning tasks seem to take longer and longer. Water consumption is high. Chemical products must be replenished frequently. Teams sometimes adjust the settings to achieve a satisfactory result.
Taken separately, each of these elements may seem to be part of the normal costs of operating a food or dairy plant. However, taken together, they can reveal a much more costly problem: a CIP system that is poorly sized or not adapted to the process it is intended to clean.
The true cost of a CIP system (Clean in Place) is therefore not limited to its purchase price. It is also measured every day in terms of lost production time, water, energy, chemicals and risks associated with inadequate cleaning.
The right question is not just: «Does my CIP clean?»
It’s more like: «Does it clean effectively, in a repeatable manner and at the appropriate cost?»
Why can a CIP that works still cost too much?
A CIP system allows the internal surfaces of tanks, piping, pumps, valves and other process equipment to be cleaned without having to disassemble the installation.
To achieve effective cleaning, several parameters must work together: time, temperature, concentration of chemical products, and mechanical action created by, for example, the circulation of the liquid.
When one of these parameters is inadequate, the instinctive reaction is often to compensate with the others.
Is the flow insufficient? We prolong the cycle.
The cleaning is irregular? We increase the concentration of the product.
Some residues persist? Rinse longer.
This strategy can allow the system to «work», but it shifts the problem to operational costs.
A longer cleaning cycle immobilizes the equipment. An additional amount of water must be pumped, sometimes heated, and then treated as wastewater. Excessive concentrations of cleaning products increase costs without necessarily improving the result.
That is why A oversized CIP is not automatically better than a under-dimensioned CIP. The goal is to design a system adapted to the circuits, the equipment, the products manufactured, and the actual health requirements of the factory.
1. Cleaning time is also production time
For a plant manager, one of the easiest losses to underestimate is time.
When a line is in CIP cycle, it is generally not available for production. A few extra minutes may seem negligible on a single cleaning. Multiplied by several cycles per day, several lines and hundreds of days of operation, they become much more significant.
Let's take a deliberately simple example.
If a cycle could be performed effectively in 45 minutes, but it takes 60 minutes to compensate for poor circulation or inadequate parameters, this means that 15 minutes of availability is lost with each cycle.
With four cycles per day, that amounts to one hour.
Out of 250 days of production, we reach 250 hours of potentially immobilized capacity.
This does not automatically mean 250 hours of recoverable production: each plant has its own constraints and its own schedule. But the example shows why cleaning time must be viewed as a financial data, and not just a health-related one.
Before investing in a new line to increase capacity, it may therefore be appropriate to ask: How many hours does our current installation actually dedicate to cleaning, and how many of those hours are necessary?
2. Water costs more than the price shown on the water bill
Water consumption is probably the most visible indicator of an ineffective CIP.
But calculating only the price per cubic meter of water gives an incomplete picture.
The water used during a cycle must be routed into the system. Depending on the cleaning stage, it may need to be heated. Pumps consume electricity to circulate it. After use, it must be drained and, depending on the installation, treated.
In other words, A useless liter of water can lead to several indirect costs.
This becomes particularly important when rinses are extended to compensate for a system whose flow rate, configuration, or sequences are not optimized.
On a cycle scale, the difference may seem modest. On a scale of a factory that operates year-round, it can represent a considerable volume.
To understand the real cost of CIP, it is therefore necessary to measure not only the amount of water consumed per cycle, but also the number of cycles performed and the costs associated with heating, pumping, and treating the effluents.
3. More chemicals do not necessarily mean better cleaning
This is another costly reflex: increasing the concentration of the detergent when a cleaning process produces unsatisfactory results.
However, each product has specific usage conditions. A concentration too low can reduce the cleaning efficiency, but a concentration higher than required does not necessarily lead to a better result.
It can simply increase the cost of the cycle and the chemical load of the effluents.
The same reasoning applies to temperature and time.
The goal is not to maximize each parameter individually. It is necessary to find the optimal combination of parameters. the combination that produces reliable cleaning with the resources actually needed.
This is precisely where sizing and system design become important.
4. Inadequate flow can hide the real problem
In a sanitary pipework, the cleaning liquid must generate enough mechanical action to remove the residues from the surfaces.
If the actual flow rate is not suitable for the diameter of the piping and the circuit to be cleaned, increasing the time or the chemical concentration does not necessarily correct the cause of the problem.
The system as a whole must then be examined: dimensions of the piping, load losses, pump capacity, length and configuration of the circuits, equipment crossed and actual operating conditions.
This is an important distinction.
Designing a CIP is not simply about choosing a more powerful pump or a larger tank.
A system that is too large can also lead to unnecessary costs: higher initial investment, larger volumes of solutions, increased energy consumption, or equipment that is not properly adapted to actual needs.
The right system is therefore neither the largest nor the most expensive. It is the one that provides the right cleaning conditions in the right places.
5. The most important cost may be the one that is yet to be seen
Water, chemicals and energy appear on bills.
The health risk, however, is much less visible.
A CIP can complete its cycle normally without all surfaces necessarily being cleaned optimally. Difficult-to-clean areas, inadequate circulation, or unstable parameters can favor the presence of residues.
In a food or dairy environment, the consequences can far exceed the cost of cleaning itself: resumption of cleaning, unplanned shutdown, non-compliant product, batch rejected or quality investigation.
This is what makes CIP problems particularly misleading.
A plant can save a few minutes on a poorly designed cycle and lose much more if the cleaning quality is not repeatable.
The goal is therefore not to achieve the shortest possible cycle, But the shortest cycle allows reliably achieving the required level of cleanliness.
How do you know if your CIP is really effective?
It is not necessary to wait for a failure to start asking questions.
Some indicators deserve analysis:
- the cycles are taking longer and longer;
- the water consumption for cleaning is high or increasing;
- operators must regularly modify the parameters;
- The amount of chemicals used varies greatly;
- Certain sections of the process require additional cleaning;
- production is delayed in restarting after the cycles;
- quality problems or contamination appear without an obvious cause.
Only one of these signs does not prove that the CIP is poorly designed. However, they are good reasons to look more closely at the data.
Critical parameters such as flow rate, temperature, time and concentration can be monitored in order to compare the expected performance with the actual performance of the system.
How much does a CIP cycle actually cost?
For a plant manager, a simple calculation can already reveal a lot.
Start by documenting, for a typical cycle:
CIP cost = water + chemicals + energy + effluent treatment + labor + value of the production time immobilized.
Then multiply this amount by the number of daily cycles and the number of annual production days.
The result can completely change the way an improvement project is evaluated.
A modification that seems costly when compared solely to the price of the equipment can become logical when it allows to reduce each cycle for several years.
Conversely, replacing an entire system is not always necessary. In some cases, a modification of the piping, instrumentation, sequences, pumps, or cleaning devices may be sufficient.
That is why the diagnosis must precede the solution.
Should you replace or optimize your CIP system?
Not necessarily replace.
Before recommending new equipment, it is necessary to understand why the current system consumes so much energy.
The problem may stem from the initial design, but also from a plant that has evolved since its installation. A new line may have been added. The recipes have changed. An additional tank now uses the same circuit. Production volumes have increased.
A properly designed CIP ten years ago may no longer correspond to today’s conditions.
The analysis should consider, in particular, the existing circuits, the required flow rates, the capacities of pumps and tanks, temperatures, concentrations, cycle times, and the possibilities for recovery or reuse of solutions when the process allows for it.
Design according to the process, not according to a standard solution
At Aran, the design of a CIP system is rooted in a broader understanding of the liquid process.
The company designs, manufactures, and installs stainless steel process systems and custom sanitary equipment. This approach allows for examining not only the CIP skid but also its interaction with the tanks, pumps, valves, and piping it must clean.
This vision is particularly important when an existing installation needs to be modified. Effective improvement does not necessarily consist of installing more equipment. It consists of identifying where are the losses located and what changes can actually reduce them.
Sometimes the answer will be a new system.
Sometimes it will be targeted optimization.
In both cases, the calculation should start from the same place: the actual needs of the process.
The cheapest CIP is not necessarily the one that costs the least to buy.
When two CIP solutions are compared, the acquisition cost is easy to measure. The cost of operation over five, ten or fifteen years is much less.
Yet this is where most of the differences are found.
A few extra minutes per cycle. A few hundred liters of water. A slightly excessive chemical concentration. A pump that consumes more than necessary.
Taken individually, these differences seem small.
Repeated daily for years, they become cash flow.
Before considering cleaning as a mere mandatory downtime, ask yourself one final question:
How much does each cycle cost us today, and what part of this cost is actually necessary?
The answer often helps to determine whether the current system should be continued, optimized, or a new solution should be planned.
Discover more articles
Modular skid or custom installation? Timelines, downtime costs, access and space: questions to ask to speed up your…
Corrosion, cracks, repeated repairs: discover 5 signs that an stainless steel tank needs to be repaired or replaced.