3 common mistakes in the design of liquid process systems (and how to avoid them)
On a superficial level, a few extra inches of piping, a slightly different pump, or the relocation of equipment may seem like minor details.
On the ground, these decisions can have consequences for years to come.
Insufficient flow rate, unnecessary energy consumption, difficult cleaning, complex maintenance, modifications after installation: in a liquid process system, some of the most costly errors arise well before manufacturing.
The problem is that they are not always obvious when approving the plans.
For a plant manager, an engineer or a project manager, the question then becomes: How do we know if the provider that designs the system actually has the necessary experience to anticipate these problems?
Price and timing obviously matter. But the quality of a design is also measured by what was planned before the equipment arrived on the production floor.
Here are three common mistakes that help to understand why the design experience and the field experience must work together.
Error 1: dimensioning the piping without considering the entire process
Choosing the diameter of a pipe can seem relatively simple.
The desired flow rate is known; a corresponding diameter is selected and the design is continued.
In reality, the calculation does not stop there.
The diameter influences, among other things, the speed of the liquid and the charge losses. The circuit also includes elbows, valves, exchangers, filters, connectors, and various equipment that influence its behavior.
A piping system that is too small can create significant power losses and require more power from the pump.
Conversely, an unnecessarily large piping system is not automatically preferable. It can increase the volume of product or cleaning solution contained in the system, affect flow rates, and increase manufacturing and installation costs.
The correct diameter is therefore the one that corresponds to the process as a whole, and not simply to a standard dimension used on a previous project.
A decision that also influences the cleaning
In a healthcare environment, the issue does not only concern production.
The piping must also be able to be cleaned effectively.
A circuit can very well allow the product to circulate properly during production, but present different conditions during a CIP cycle.
That is why the design of the process and that of cleaning should not be treated as two completely independent subjects.
The designer must ask himself:
Which product flows along this line?
At what speed?
What is its viscosity?
What are the load losses in the circuit?
How will it be cleaned?
What happens if production increases in a few years?
These questions taken together give a much more useful picture than just the diameter of the pipe.
How can this mistake be avoided?
The sizing must be based on the actual conditions of use.
This involves considering the minimum and maximum flow rates, the characteristics of the product, the lengths of piping, elevation changes, accessories, connected equipment, and cleaning requirements.
Good design must also look beyond the nominal functionality.
What happens when several devices are operating simultaneously?
What happens during the cleaning?
What happens if the capacity increases?
It is often these scenarios that reveal the limitations of a design before they become production problems.
Mistake 2: Choosing a pump solely based on the desired flow rate
«We need 200 liters per minute. Find a pump that provides 200 liters per minute.»
The reasoning seems logical.
But a pump does not operate independently of the network in which it is installed.
The actual flow rate obtained depends on the characteristics of the pump. and system resistance: diameter and length of pipes, elevation difference, valves, connections, equipment, and other sources of load losses.
Two installations requiring the same flow rate may therefore require very different solutions.
The nature of the product also matters.
Pumping water does not impose the same constraints as moving a more viscous liquid or a product sensitive to shear.
That is why selecting a pump solely based on a nominal flow rate can lead to an installation that works on paper, but performs less well in real-world conditions.
Oversizing «just to be sure» can also be expensive
When there is uncertainty, the temptation may be to choose a more powerful pump.
After all, a little extra capacity seems to offer a margin of safety.
But bigger is not automatically safer or more effective.
Overly oversized equipment can lead to unnecessary energy consumption and operating conditions that are far from their optimal operating point. Depending on the process, excessive speed or pressure can also be undesirable.
The best choice is therefore not the pump with the largest capacity.
It is the one that meets the real conditions of the system with an appropriate margin.
How can this mistake be avoided?
The pump and the network must be analyzed as a single unit.
This includes the required flow rate, the necessary pressure, load losses, the properties of the liquid, the suction conditions, the possible variations in the process, and how the equipment will operate in different situations.
Maintenance must also be considered.
Is the pump accessible?
Can it be easily isolated?
Will disassembly require the removal of other equipment?
A few hours dedicated to these questions during design can avoid many more hours of modifications and downtime after installation.
Mistake 3: Designing a perfect system on screen, but difficult to use in the field
It is probably the error that most clearly distinguishes a theoretical conception from one nurtured by field experience.
A system can be technically functional on a 3D drawing and become extremely frustrating once installed.
A valve is located behind another conduit.
An operator cannot easily reach an instrument.
A pump lacks space to be disassembled.
An important piece of equipment is placed in an area where maintenance teams have difficulty intervening.
Or, everything fits perfectly within the available space, but no one has planned enough clearance to replace a component.
The system works.
But each intervention takes twice as long as it should.
The available space is not just a constraint of dimensions.
In an existing plant, space constraints are often significant.
Sometimes it is necessary to integrate new equipment into already existing systems, respect the structure of the building, and maintain safe passageways.
However, the most compact solution is not necessarily the best.
A good implantation should consider at least the following:
the access of operators;
the spaces necessary for maintenance;
the disassembly of the pumps and valves;
access to the instrumentation;
the cleaning;
the circulation around the equipment;
and the future changes that are reasonably foreseeable.
These elements may seem secondary when the main objective is to get the system into the available space.
They become essential from the first maintenance intervention onwards.
How can this mistake be avoided?
You must design the system with the person who will be using it in five years in mind.
Not just those who approve the plan today.
This is where field experience becomes particularly important.
A designer who understands how equipment is manufactured, welded, installed, cleaned, and maintained can spot problems that a technical drawing does not immediately show.
Why do these errors become so costly after installation?
Before fabrication, moving a pump may sometimes require some modifications to the drawing.
After installation, the same change may require cutting off piping, re-welding, modifying supports, moving instrumentation, and interrupting production.
That’s the whole difference between correct a decision and correcting an installation.
The later an error is detected, the greater the number of affected elements can be.
That is why the time devoted to engineering at the beginning of the project should not be seen solely as a step to shorten the time required to start manufacturing more quickly.
It is used to reduce the unknowns before they become stainless steel installed in the factory.
How to evaluate a provider’s experience before entrusting your system to them?
Years of experience are useful, but they do not tell the whole story.
During the preliminary discussions, pay special attention to the questions the provider asks you.
Is he only looking for the speed and dimensions?
Or does he want to understand the product, the production sequences, the cleaning, the space constraints, the existing equipment, the maintenance, and the future projects?
An experienced provider should also be able to explain the compromises.
Why this diameter?
Why this pump?
Why is this equipment placed here?
What does this option get you?
What is it that we sacrifice?
A credible answer is not always: «Here is the best solution.»
It can be: «Here are the two options, here’s what they entail, and here’s why one probably suits your situation better.»
This ability to explain compromises is often much more revealing than a sales argument.
When design, manufacture and installation speak the same language
Another point deserves consideration: the continuity between those who design the system and those who will have to manufacture and install it.
A technically correct design must also be able to be manufactured and installed effectively under the actual conditions of the factory.
At Aran, senior engineers work with the teams responsible for stainless steel fabrication, piping, welding, and installation.
This continuity allows the realities of the field to be integrated earlier in the project.
With more than 20 years of experience in the design of liquid process systems and tanks, the goal is not to make a system more complex than necessary.
Rather, it is about identifying the problems at the level where they are still relatively easy to correct.
Good design avoids problems that you should never have to face.
The best engineering decisions are sometimes invisible.
You won’t see the pump that would have been oversized, because it was properly selected from the start.
You will not see the piping that would have had to be modified after installation, because load losses were considered during design.
You might never notice that a valve could have been inaccessible, because the maintenance space was planned before manufacture.
That is precisely the goal.
When evaluating the design of a liquid process system, therefore, do not simply ask whether the system will work.
Also ask:
Will it be effective? Cleanable? Accessible? Maintainable? And will it still be able to meet our needs as our production evolves?
It is often in the responses to these questions that a provider’s experience becomes truly visible.
Discover more articles
Modular skid or custom installation? Timelines, downtime costs, access and space: questions to ask to speed up your…
Corrosion, cracks, repeated repairs: discover 5 signs that an stainless steel tank needs to be repaired or replaced.