Custom-made: why standard equipment isn't always enough

When a plant needs to add a tank, skid, or new equipment to its process system, the standard option offers obvious advantages. It is generally cheaper to purchase, its design is already available, and the lead times can be shorter.

When its characteristics truly correspond to the needs of the process, there is no reason to complicate the project with fully customized manufacturing.

The situation changes when the equipment needs to be integrated into an existing plant, in a limited space or with specific requirements regarding flow rate, cleaning or compatibility with existing installations. A standard model may then appear economical on the quote, while requiring a series of adaptations that gradually increase the actual cost of the project.

The question is therefore not whether the customized product is «better» than the standard one. What needs to be determined is which solution best meets the process with the fewest compromises, once the equipment is installed and operational.

When is a standard equipment sufficient?

In many projects, a standard equipment is perfectly suited.

If its capacity meets the needs, the flow rates are compatible, the materials are suitable for the product, and the equipment fits properly into the available space, the custom-made solution may bring little added value.

It is also necessary to verify that the integration does not compromise cleaning, maintenance or access to the various components. When all these elements are taken into account, choosing a standard solution often allows for reducing costs and timeframes without sacrificing performance.

The role of an experienced supplier is therefore not to systematically recommend a special manufacturing process. It is rather to recognize At what point do the constraints of the project begin to make the standard less advantageous than it appears to be?.

1. When the available space requires too many compromises

In an existing plant, new equipment rarely arrives in a completely empty space. You have to deal with the tanks already installed, the piping, the building structures, the circulation areas, and the equipment that cannot be moved.

The dimensions listed on a technical sheet are therefore not enough to determine whether a piece of equipment is truly suitable. One must also consider how it will be used once installed.

Will the team have easy access to the valves and instrumentation? Will there be enough space to remove a pump or perform maintenance? Will the traffic around the equipment remain safe?

A standard model can thus physically fit into the available space without actually fitting in well.

If it is then necessary to modify the piping route, add elbows, manufacture special supports or move other components, the savings achieved through the purchase begin to decrease quickly.

In this situation, the correct comparison is no longer between the catalog price of a standard equipment and that of a customized equipment. One must compare the cost of the two solutions once installed and operational.

2. When your process does not match the standard parameters

Two plants in the same sector may have very different needs. Flow rates, temperatures, product viscosities, volumes, production sequences, and cleaning methods can vary considerably.

A standard equipment is designed to operate within a specific range of conditions. As long as the process comfortably falls within this range, this approach works very well.

Difficulties begin when the installation must constantly operate close to the limits of the equipment or when the process itself must be modified to adapt to it.

Let’s take the case of a liquid process system. The choice of a tank influences the available volumes, while the selection of pumps and the diameter of the piping influence the flow conditions. Cleaning then adds its own requirements.

These decisions are linked to each other.

A customized design allows us to start from the actual conditions of the process and then determine which elements need to be adapted. This does not mean that every component must be manufactured specifically, but rather that important decisions are not dictated solely by the limitations of an existing product.

3. When the new equipment must be integrated into an existing installation

Integration is often much simpler in a new plant, where the equipment can be positioned relative to one another from the design stage.

In an already production-line facility, the constraints are different. The connection heights have been established; some tanks or pumps must be retained, and the piping already follows its own path.

Sometimes an existing control system, equipment of different generations, and a very limited period must be added to this, during which production can be interrupted to carry out the work.

In this context, a standard, high-performance equipment may lose some of its advantage if several systems around it have to be modified to allow its installation.

A solution designed around the existing structure allows these constraints to be integrated from the outset. The goal is to reduce the need for improvised adjustments on site and to make the installation as predictable as possible.

This is particularly important when every hour of production downtime counts.

4. When adaptations complicate cleaning

In the food, dairy, brewing, beverage, pharmaceutical or cosmetic industries, equipment must not only operate properly during production; it must also be able to be cleaned effectively and repetitively.

This is where an apparently minor adaptation can have unexpected consequences.

Adding piping to connect standard equipment can change the flow conditions during a CIP cycle. A more complex geometry can make certain areas more difficult to clean, while the addition of fittings or components increases the number of surfaces to inspect and maintain.

This does not mean that a standard equipment is ill-suited to sanitary procedures. In many cases, it is perfectly suitable.

You just have to assess the installation as a whole.

If the savings realized when purchasing lead to longer cleaning cycles, more manual interventions, or higher consumption of water and chemicals, the financial calculation changes.

5. When your production capacity needs to evolve

Future growth is another reason to consider the configuration of the system, but it does not automatically justify over-sizing the equipment.

Buying a much larger system today simply because production could increase in a few years can unnecessarily immobilize capital. Depending on the process, this can also increase some operating costs.

Conversely, ignoring already predictable growth can force the plant to modify its installation much earlier than expected.

An adapted design allows for a balance between the two.

For example, some connections may be provided for future expansion; the layout of the equipment can preserve the space needed for a future addition, or a skid can be designed to facilitate modification.

In this case, customization does not necessarily mean building larger products. It rather allows for customization. meeting current needs without unnecessarily closing the door to tomorrow's needs.

How much does a custom solution actually cost?

It is often here that the comparison becomes interesting.

A custom solution generally requires more engineering and specific manufacturing. Its initial price may therefore be higher than that of a comparable standard equipment.

But the purchase price only represents a part of the project.

To compare the two options, it is also necessary to consider the necessary modifications in the plant, piping, installation, commissioning, production stops, and the future costs of cleaning, operating, and maintaining.

A standard equipment costing 20 % less at purchase may remain the best option after this analysis. But if its integration requires significant work, part of that savings may disappear even before production begins.

The opposite is also true: paying more for custom-made manufacturing only makes sense if that difference brings tangible value.

This value can take several forms: fewer modifications on site, faster installation, better access for maintenance, simplified cleaning, or better integration into the existing process.

The calculation should therefore be based on the total cost of the solution, Rather than on the price of a piece of equipment taken in isolation.

Customized doesn't mean making everything to order.

This is an important distinction.

A custom system does not need to be composed solely of unique parts. In reality, unnecessarily customizing each component can increase costs and complicate maintenance or the supply of replacement parts.

An effective design instead seeks to use proven standard components wherever they properly meet the need.

A skid can, for example, use standard pumps, valves and instrumentation while possessing a structure and piping configuration specifically adapted to the available space.

The approach can be summarized simply: Standardize what can be standardized and customize what truly adds value.

This way of working allows you to take advantage of the benefits of customization without making the system unnecessarily complex.

Why design, manufacturing and installation should work together

A customized project involves several stages. The needs must be understood and translated into design, then this design must be able to be manufactured and finally installed under the actual conditions of the factory.

When these steps are completely separate, certain constraints can appear late in the project. A simple detail that can be easily modified on a plan can become much more complex once the parts are manufactured or the piping installed.

At Aran, the design, manufacture and installation of stainless steel process systems and equipment can be carried out within a single project chain.

The engineers thus work in conjunction with the manufacturing teams, the TIG welders, the polishers and the fitters, who will have to transform the design into a real installation.

This continuity does not mean that a project will be free of unforeseen issues. It mainly allows for earlier consideration of the manufacturing and installation realities, while adjustments are still relatively simple to make.

For a custom project, this is often where a significant part of the value lies: resolve constraints before they become costly changes on the ground.

So, standard or custom-made?

The answer depends less on the category of equipment than on the number of constraints the project must meet.

If a standard solution corresponds to the process, the available space, the health requirements, and the existing equipment, it may perfectly represent the best choice. Paying more simply to obtain customized manufacturing does not necessarily bring any benefit.

When several adaptations become necessary, however, one must look beyond the purchase price. Site modifications, additional piping, cleaning constraints, maintenance, and installation time must all be factored into the calculation.

It is often at this point that customization becomes relevant.

Not because it would automatically be more efficient or more sophisticated, but because it allows the equipment to be adapted to the real constraints of the factory rather than accumulating compromises to adapt the factory to the equipment.

Ultimately, the best solution remains the one that best suits the process with the least unnecessary complexity and whose cost remains consistent throughout its entire lifespan.

Discover more articles

Modular skid vs custom installation: which option speeds up your production launch?

Modular skid or custom installation? Timelines, downtime costs, access and space: questions to ask to speed up your…

Stainless steel tank: 5 signs that it’s time to replace yours

Corrosion, cracks, repeated repairs: discover 5 signs that an stainless steel tank needs to be repaired or replaced.