What the sanitary standards really require for process piping

In an agro-food, pharmaceutical or cosmetic plant, a stainless steel pipe may seem perfectly compliant at first glance: it is clean, the welds appear solid and the system operates as intended. However, this is not necessarily sufficient to meet health requirements.

An installation may have difficult-to-clean areas, inadequate welds, excessively rough surfaces, or places where the product and cleaning solutions may accumulate. These details are sometimes invisible during normal production, but can become problematic during an audit or cleaning validation.

Sanitary compliance therefore does not depend solely on the choice of stainless steel. It begins with the design of the piping and continues throughout its manufacture, installation, cleaning, and maintenance. So, what really distinguishes a sanitary process piping system from a conventional industrial piping system?

A sanitary pipework must first be able to be cleaned.

This is probably the most important principle to remember. In a sanitary process, the goal is not only to transport a liquid from point A to point B. The system must also be able to be cleaned effectively in order to prevent product residues, contaminants, or microorganisms from accumulating.

Cleanability, accessibility for inspection, and the ability of surfaces to drain properly are therefore important factors to consider. This influences virtually every design decision: the geometry of the network, fittings, valves, welds, the interior finish, and even the slope of certain sections.

In other words, an installation can be mechanically functional while being ill-suited to a sanitary environment.

Why is the interior finish so important?

In a sanitary pipe system, the quality of the surface matters. The more irregularities, cracks, or crevices a surface has, the more likely it is to retain residues and the more difficult it becomes to clean it. That is why sanitary requirements not only apply to the material used, but also to the surface condition of the material.

For some healthcare applications, the surfaces in contact with the product may need to meet a specific level of roughness. A commonly used reference is a roughness of 32 micro-inches Ra (0.8 µm Ra) or smoother, Depending on the equipment, application, and requirements applicable to the project, the figure may seem very technical. However, its purpose is simple: to obtain a surface sufficiently smooth and free of defects to facilitate effective cleaning.

In pharmaceutical applications, the requirements can be even more precise depending on the product, process and cleaning protocol. Finishing is therefore not just an aesthetic consideration: in a sanitary facility, it directly contributes to the system’s cleanability.

The welds are part of the sanitary surface

Excellent plumbing can lose much of its benefits if its welds create irregularities within the network. A weld in contact with the product must be made in such a way as to limit crevices, defects, and geometries that could retain product or make cleaning more difficult.

This is also why processes such as orbital welding can be particularly interesting for certain healthcare facilities. They allow for precise and repeatable welds when required. Aran has expertise in orbital welding, TIG welding, and process piping installation.

But the welding method is only one element. The quality of execution, finishing and inspection remain equally important.

Retention zones are the enemy of a healthcare system

Imagine a small section of piping in which product remains trapped after production. Even if the majority of the network is perfectly cleaned, this area can retain liquid or residues. It then becomes much more difficult to clean and sanitize in a reproducible manner.

It is for this reason that sanitary design seeks to limit dead zones, crevasses, pockets and other places where the product or cleaning solutions can accumulate.

The drainage capacity of the network becomes essential. The surfaces and the different sections of the piping must be designed in such a way as to facilitate the evacuation of liquids when the process requires it. The connections, seals, valves and other components must also be considered from the design stage.

These are sometimes very small details on a plan. In the day-to-day operation of a factory, however, they can make a big difference.

A CIP system does not correct a bad design

Clean-in-Place (CIP) cleaning allows certain installations to be cleaned without dismantling the entire network. This is a particularly interesting solution for sanitary processes, but there is an important misconception that needs to be corrected: installing a CIP system does not automatically make an installation hygienic.

Cleaning must be able to effectively reach all affected surfaces. If the system’s geometry creates areas that are poorly drained or difficult to reach, simply increasing the duration or intensity of cleaning does not necessarily solve the problem. The design of the equipment, materials, operating conditions, and cleaning products used must all work together.

This sums up the challenge well: Cleanability should not be added at the end of a project; it must be integrated into its design.

Connectors and valves also count

A sanitary pipework is never made up solely of tubes. It includes valves, fittings, sealing gaskets, instruments and various transitions. Each of these elements can become a sensitive point if it is not adapted to the application.

In a sanitary environment, the choice of a valve therefore does not depend solely on its diameter, its nominal pressure or its ability to control the flow rate. It is also necessary to ask: how will this valve be cleaned?

The same principle applies to connections and seals. Their design must allow for proper cleaning and minimize the number of places where product can collect. These are the types of questions that help avoid discovering a problem once the installation is complete.

Food, pharmaceutical and cosmetics: the requirements are not identical

It would be tempting to seek a single list of criteria applicable to all sanitary facilities. In practice, this is not as simple: the applicable standards and requirements can vary depending on the sector, product, process, market, and the specific requirements of the client.

In the food and beverage industry, hygienic design principles include materials, surfaces, seals, drainage, cleaning, and inspection. In the pharmaceutical industry, design, documentation, and validation requirements can be different or more extensive depending on the application. Cosmetic processes also present their own constraints based on the products manufactured and the production conditions.

Therefore, it is necessary to avoid an assertion such as: «This plumbing is sanitary, therefore it is automatically compliant everywhere.» The correct installation is the one that is designed based on the requirements that are actually applicable to the project.

Why do problems sometimes only appear during an audit?

Because a system can function properly without being easily cleaned or inspected. A pump can operate. A line can transport the product at the correct flow rate. A tank can fulfill its role. None of these alone guarantees that the installation meets applicable sanitary criteria.

An audit or inspection can highlight elements that did not directly affect production: a retention area, an area difficult to inspect, an inadequate seal, or a cleaning method difficult to validate.

Correcting these problems after installation may involve disassembly, new welds, the replacement of certain components, or even a production shutdown. That is why Compliance usually costs less when it is planned before manufacturing rather than after an audit.

How to reduce the risk before production begins?

An plant manager or project manager does not need to become an expert in all health standards in order to properly supervise his installation. He must above all ensure that the right questions are asked early enough:

  • What standards and requirements actually apply to our process?
  • What surface finish is required?
  • How will the network be cleaned and maintained?
  • Can the system drain properly?
  • Are there any areas that could retain product?
  • Are the valves, fittings and seals suitable for a sanitary application?
  • How will the welds be made, finished and inspected?
  • What documents or validation elements will be required during an audit?

These responses should influence the design even before the first sections of piping are manufactured.

Compliance begins before the first weld

A compliant sanitary installation is not based on a single component, finish or standard. It is the result of a set of coherent decisions: appropriate materials, cleanable surfaces, controlled welds, suitable connections, drainage, design for cleaning and the possibility of inspecting the system.

Aran designs, manufactures and installs customized stainless steel process equipment and systems. Its expertise includes process piping, orbital welding, skids and stainless steel tanks.

For a plant manager, engineer, or project manager, the goal is not to know every line of every health standard. The goal is to ensure that applicable requirements are identified at the outset and integrated into the design, manufacture, and installation process. This upstream work helps reduce the risk of discovering non-compliance during an audit when the equipment is already installed and production is imminent.

Discover more articles

Modular skid vs custom installation: which option speeds up your production launch?

Modular skid or custom installation? Timelines, downtime costs, access and space: questions to ask to speed up your…

Stainless steel tank: 5 signs that it’s time to replace yours

Corrosion, cracks, repeated repairs: discover 5 signs that an stainless steel tank needs to be repaired or replaced.

Custom-made: why standard equipment isn't always enough

Standard equipment or custom-made fabrication? Discover when custom-made becomes relevant for an industrial liquid process system.

3 Responses